Skip to Main Content
The Muddy Rudder logo topThe Muddy Rudder logo scroll
  • (207)-846-3082
  • info@muddy-rudder.com
  • 1335 Route 1 , Yarmouth
  • MENU
  • SPECIALS
  • CATERING
  • EVENTS
  • PARTIES
  • GIFT CARDS
  • JOBS
  • ORDER
  • RESERVE
  • Twitter pageFacebook pageYelp page
The Muddy Rudder logo topThe Muddy Rudder logo scroll
  • Twitter pageFacebook pageYelp page
  • MENU
  • SPECIALS
  • CATERING
  • EVENTS
  • PARTIES
  • GIFT CARDS
  • JOBS
  • ORDER
  • RESERVE

Our Menu

MenuDesserts

• Gluten Free option Available | Shared Plate (Entrees, Sandwiches, and Salads) $5 | * Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish, or eggs may increase your risk of foodborne illness. | Menu items and pricing are subject to change without notice.

Appetizers

Rudder Chips •

$6.00
House-fried potato chips with Parmesan cream, crumbled bacon, and scallions | Add chicken +$2, shrimp +$2, braised short rib +$2

Shrimp Cocktail •

$10.00
Five shrimp and cocktail sauce

Seafood Cake

$13.00
Haddock, shrimp, and crabmeat with onions, peppers, and corn, served with remoulade sauce

Popcorn Shrimp

$12.00
With cocktail sauce

Mussels •

$17.00
PEI mussels tossed with scampi butter, white wine, chorizo, caramelized onions, and roasted tomato

Reuben Egg Rolls

$12.00
Two egg rolls filled with corned beef, sauerkraut, and Swiss cheese, with thousand island dressing

Fried Calamari

$14.00
Lightly fried, with our house Asian chili sauce

Fried Clams *

MP
With house-made tartar sauce.

Pot Stickers

$10.00
Steamed pork pot stickers tossed in a sweet Asian chili sauce, topped with scallions

Rolls

$3.00
Two baked-to-order rolls served with our brown sugar butter

Fried Scallops

With tartar sauce

Salads & Soups

Add to any Salad or Pasta: 5 Grilled Shrimp • $10, *Grilled Marinated Steak Tips • $12, Grilled Chicken Breast • $6, Fried Calamari $10, Fried Haddock $10, Seafood Cake $10 Popcorn Shrimp $10, 4 ounces Lobster Meat • $MP, Grilled, Blackened, or Honey-Garlic Salmon • $12

New England Clam Chowder •

$6.00/Cup
$8.00/Bowl
Traditional!

Traditional Lobster Bisque •

$6.00/Cup
$8.00/Bowl
Lobster stock, sherry and cream | Add 4oz Lobster Meat at Market Price

French Onion Soup

$8.00/Crock
With toasted baguette and Swiss cheese

Chili & Cornbread

$7.00/Cup
$10.00/Bowl
Beef chili with beans topped with scallions and sour cream, with a side of house-made cornbread.
Caesar Salad • photo

Caesar Salad •

$10.00
Romaine, Parmesan cheese, croutons, and our Caesar dressing

Demi Caesar Salad •

$6.00
Spinach Salad • photo

Spinach Salad •

$12.00
Spinach, shaved Brussels sprouts, butternut squash, dried cranberries, toasted pecans, and Parmesan crisps with a bacon vinaigrette
Rudder Wedge Salad • photo

Rudder Wedge Salad •

$12.00
Halved Romaine heart, red onion, roasted tomato, bacon, bleu cheese dressing

Pasta Dishes

Gluten-free Pasta $2 | Add to any Salad or Pasta: 5 Grilled Shrimp • $10, *Grilled Marinated Steak Tips • $12, Grilled Chicken Breast • $6, Fried Calamari $10, Fried Haddock $10, Seafood Cake $10 Popcorn Shrimp $10, 4 ounces Lobster Meat • $MP, Grilled, Blackened, or Honey-Garlic Salmon • $12

Seafood Scampi *• photo

Seafood Scampi *•

$26.00
Scallops, shrimp, and mussels sautéed with roasted tomatoes in our house scampi sauce, served on linguine

Chicken Pasta •

$21.00
Grilled Chicken, cavatappi pasta, with bacon, roasted tomatoes, and spinach, in a Parmesan cream sauce

Risotto •

$21.00
Creamy risotto with roasted butternut squash, toasted pepitas, and Parmesan cheese

Mac & Cheese •

$18.00
Cavatappi pasta with a creamy cheese sauce

Lobster Mac 'N' Cheese •

MP
Our Mac & Cheese with a quarter pound of Lobster Meat | Double Lobster also possible

Seafood Lasagna

$34.00
Crabmeat, scallops, and shrimp, layered with lasagna pasta, spinach, and our ricotta cheese blend with a Béchamel sauce, served with a demi Caesar salad

Entrées

Served with two sides unless note different.

Maple-Bourbon Steak Tips •

$25.00
Marinated and grilled to order, with mashed potatoes and green beans (recommended served medium) | Add Sautéed Mushrooms and Onions $2

Chicken Parmigiana

$21.00
Breaded boneless chicken breast, prosciutto, mozzarella, and red sauce on spaghetti

Pork Tenderloin •

$23.00
Cider-brined pork tenderloin with maple-mustard sauce, with roasted sweet potatoes and bacon Brussels sprouts
Baked Haddock • photo

Baked Haddock •

$23.00
Seasoned crumbs, lobster sherry cream sauce, with garlic herbed rice, and roasted carrots
Seafood Stuffed Haddock photo

Seafood Stuffed Haddock

$28.00
Our seafood stuffing, lobster sherry cream sauce, with garlic herbed rice, and roasted carrots

Braised Short Rib •

$24.00
Red wine-braised boneless short rib, with garlic mashed potato, and roasted carrots

Honey-Garlic Salmon *•

$26.00
Grilled, with mashed sweet potatoes, and garlic-sautéed baby spinach
14-ounce NY Strip Steak • photo

14-ounce NY Strip Steak •

$36.00
Grilled to order, roasted garlic demi-glace, mushroom risotto, and green beans | Add 5 Grilled Shrimp $10.00, add Sautéed Mushrooms & Onions $2.00

Sandwiches

Served with one side and a pickle | Sandwich Sides: French Fries, Mashed Potato, Roasted Carrots, Garlic Sautéed Baby Spinach, Cole Slaw, House-Fried Chips Sweet Potato Fries $2, Onion Rings $2, Mac & Cheese $2, Lobster Mac & Cheese at Market Price, Bacon Brussels Sprouts $3

Burger *

$14.00
Hand-formed, grilled to order, with lettuce, tomato, and onion | Add Cheese $2, add Bacon $2, add Sautéed Mushrooms and Onions $2
Rudder Burger photo

Rudder Burger

$16.00
Our signature burger, grilled to order, topped with roasted garlic beef demi-glace, bleu cheese, and onion rings

Fried Haddock Sandwich

$14.00
With lettuce, tomato, onion, a side of cole slaw, tartar sauce

Lobster Croissant

MP
¼ pound fresh-picked lobster meat, lettuce, and lemon aioli on a flaky croissant, or warm with drawn butter +$2

Fried Chicken Sandwich

$14.00
Fried chicken breast with sriracha-honey aioli, shredded lettuce, tomato, and pickle on a toasted brioche bun

Caesar Wrap

$14.00
Fried haddock or grilled chicken breast, romaine lettuce, Parmesan cheese and our Caesar dressing
Seafood Cake Sandwich photo

Seafood Cake Sandwich

$16.00
Our seafood cake with lettuce, tomato, and a side of remoulade sauce

Rueben

$15.00
Corned beef, Swiss cheese, sauerkraut, and thousand island dressing served on marble rye bread

Fried Platters

Served with French Fries, cole slaw, and Tartar Sauce

Chicken

$18.00

Shrimp

$22.00
Served with cocktail sauce

Scallops

MP

Haddock

$23.00

Clams

MP

Calamari

$22.00

Seafood Cake Platter

$28.00
2 Seafood Cakes

Fisherman’s Platter

MP
Shrimp, Haddock, Clams, Scallops

Our Desserts

Chocolate Torte

$9.00
Gluten free. Flourless, rich dark chocolate drizzled with raspberry coulis

Crème Brulee

$9.00
Gluten Free. Classic, house-made chilled custard topped with flame melted sugar.
Muddy Marquise photo

Muddy Marquise

$9.00
Gluten Free. Chocolate Heath Bar mousse topped with chocolate ganache and Frangelico Creme Anglaise with hazelnut pieces, and made with imported Belgian Chocolate.
Carrot Cake photo

Carrot Cake

$9.00
House-made cheesecake-stuffed carrot cake with candied walnuts and our own buttercream frosting

Peanut Butter Pie

$9.00
House-made Oreo cookie crust, delicious peanut butter filling with crumbled Reese's Peanut Butter cups
Blueberry Pie photo

Blueberry Pie

$9.00
House-made in a traditional pastry crust filled with Maine Blueberries served with a scoop of Gifford's of Maine vanilla ice cream

Ice Cream

$6.00
Serving ice cream from Gifford's of Maine! Chocolate Lover's Chocolate Ice Cream, Coffee Ice Cream, Vanilla Ice Cream, and Seasonal Sorbet

Classic Frappes

$7.00
Vanilla, Chocolate, and Coffee

Specialty Frappes

$9.00
Chocolate Peanut butter Cup, Oreo Cookie, Blueberry Pie, Salted Caramel, and Summertime S'more
  • Order
  • Reserve
  • Parties
  • Catering
  • Jobs